Principal Timothy Mueller

 Phone:262-786-2900 (after hours office ext 101)

It is an absolute privilege to serve here at Star of Bethlehem and assist parents with the Christian upbringing of their children.  I, only through the help of our Lord, will strive to continually raise the bar of excellence in Christian education as I serve families to the fullest of my abilities.  If you have absolutely any questions, comments, or concerns, my office door, phone line (personal cell phone number is 608-567-9909), and inbox are always open to you. 

Personal Background
I grew up in a Pastor’s family in Waupun, WI and Medford, WI with two brothers and two sisters.  I attended college at UW-Milwaukee and graduated with degrees in Business Administration, Marketing, and Finance.  I then continued my education at Martin Luther College where I received my bachelor’s degree in Elementary Education and master’s degree in Educational Leadership.  From MLC, I received my first call to serve St. John’s Lutheran Church and School in Sparta, WI as their principal.  While there, I met my wife Megan, and we had our first child, Timothy III.  After 6 years of ministry in Sparta, my family joined the family here at Star of Bethlehem.  While here, the Lord blessed our family with three more children: William, Elowyn, and Michael.  God is GREAT!  Recently, I had the privilege to continue my education at MSOE and receive a masters degree in business administration with an emphasis in educational leadership.
I thoroughly enjoy spending time with my family, golfing, fishing, hunting, playing all sports, staying active, and working on my never-ending “honey-do list”. 
Education and Experience
  • Master of Business Administration
  • Wisconsin Administrator License
  • Master of Science in Education from Martin Luther College, New Ulm, MN
  • Bachelor of Business Administration in Marketing and Finance from UW-Milwaukee
  • Bachelor of Science in Education from Martin Luther College, New Ulm, MN
  • Wisconsin and Minnesota state teaching licenses
  • Principal and Teacher at St. John’s Lutheran School, Sparta, WI
  • Principal and teacher at Star of Bethlehem Lutheran School, New Berlin, WI

Other Areas of Service in the Church and School
  • Member of the Church Council and Board of Education.
  • Advisor to the Technology Committee, Finance Committee, Board of Trustees, Home and School Association, Evangelism Committee, Board of Trustees, and absolutely anyone else that I might serve.
  • Webmaster of
  • Chairman of Wisconsin Lutheran State Teachers’ Conference Program Committee
  • Webmaster of the Wisconsin Lutheran State Teachers' Conference website -
  • Chairman of the Wisconsin Lutheran High School Principals' Conference
  • Member of Task Force on Lutheran Schools
  • Member of the Wisconsin Lutheran High School Board of Directors